Argument: Native American kids not citizens; why should kids of illegals be?
"George F. Will: Citizenship a birthright?" The Commercial Appeal. March 28th, 2010: "in 1884 the Supreme Court held that children born to Indian parents were not born 'subject to' U.S. jurisdiction because, among other reasons, the person so born could not change his status by his 'own will without the action or assent of the United States.' And 'no one can become a citizen of a nation without its consent.' Graglia says this decision 'seemed to establish" that U.S. citizenship is 'a consensual relation, requiring the consent of the United States.' So: 'This would clearly settle the question of birthright citizenship for children of illegal aliens. There cannot be a more total or forceful denial of consent to a person's citizenship than to make the source of that person's presence in the nation illegal.'"