Personal tools
 
Views

Argument: Gene patents can harm patient care and pricing

From Debatepedia

Jump to: navigation, search

Parent debate

Supporting quotations

Michael Crichton. "Patenting Life." New York Times (Op-Ed). February 13, 2007: "Canavan disease is an inherited disorder that affects children starting at 3 months; they cannot crawl or walk, they suffer seizures and eventually become paralyzed and die by adolescence. Formerly there was no test to tell parents if they were at risk. Families enduring the heartbreak of caring for these children engaged a researcher to identify the gene and produce a test. Canavan families around the world donated tissue and money to help this cause. [...] When the gene was identified in 1993, the families got the commitment of a New York hospital to offer a free test to anyone who wanted it. But the researcher’s employer, Miami Children’s Hospital Research Institute, patented the gene and refused to allow any health care provider to offer the test without paying a royalty. The parents did not believe genes should be patented and so did not put their names on the patent. Consequently, they had no control over the outcome."

Problem with the site? 

Tweet a bug on bugtwits
.