Personal tools
 
Views

Argument: Cloned babies would be loved by parents that choose to have them

From Debatepedia

Jump to: navigation, search

Parent debate

Supporting quotations

Gregory E. Pence. "The Top Ten Myths about Human Cloning". Human Cloning.org - "2. Human cloning is replication or making children into commodities. Opponents of cloning often use these words to beg the question, to assume that children created by parents by a new method would not be loved. Similar things were said about "test tube" babies, who turned out to be some of the most-wanted, most-loved babies ever created in human history.

Indeed, the opposite is true: evolution has created us with sex drives such that, if we do not carefully use contraception, children occur. Because children get created this way without being wanted, sexual reproduction is more likely to create unwanted, and hence possibly unloved, children than human cloning.

Lawyers opposing cloning have a special reason for using these pejorative words. If cloning is just a new form of human reproduction, then it is Constitutionally protected from interference by the state. Several Supreme Court decisions declare that all forms of human reproduction, including the right not to reproduce, cannot be abridged by government.

Use of words such as "replication" and "commodification" also assumes artificial wombs or commercial motives; about these fallacies, see below."

Problem with the site? 

Tweet a bug on bugtwits
.